All three judges agree in Buffalo
Rube Ferns beats Mysterious Billy Smith by unanimous decision at Hawthorne Athletic Club, Buffalo. The cards read 238–233, 237–234 and 238–233 for Ferns after all twenty-five scheduled rounds.
Ferns wins the opening three rounds by the judges’ majority and retains the overall card lead. Across the full contest he takes fifteen rounds to Smith’s ten by majority vote. The ASN records now read Ferns 1–0; Smith 0–1.
The judges’ agreement and the sustained performance over the long distance earn Ferns the Historic honour. No separate title, finishing punch or knockdown count is inferred. C&D game used: Fight Card Boxing · Powder Blue Sports. The full award citation →