January 16, 1900 · American Amateur Hockey League · Canonical replay

Brooklyn holds off New York’s late charge

C&D game used: Hockey Blast · PLAAY Games · ASN historical adaptation

Brooklyn Skating Club 4–3 New York Athletic Club

Brooklyn opens its accepted ASN record at 1–0; New York A.C. starts 0–1. Two goals apiece from Williams and Liffiton withstand New York’s late rally.

Historical replay · sourced names · estimated ratings and roles · modern Hockey Blast adaptation

The match

Max Hornfeck opened the scoring for New York A.C. in the eighth minute. Williams answered at P1 · 11, and Liffiton put Brooklyn ahead at P1 · 17. A scoreless second period left Brooklyn leading 2–1.

Brooklyn struck twice in succession in the third: Williams at minute 14 and Liffiton at minute 15 made it 4–1. Hunt and Baird replied at minutes 17 and 18, but New York could not find the equalizer. Liffiton’s second goal stands as the winner.

Shiebler assisted on three Brooklyn goals; Post supplied two assists. New York’s Koehler set up both late replies. O’Donnell recorded six charted saves; C. MacKenzie had at least four. One New York attempt has an uncertain on-goal outcome, so its corresponding shot and save totals remain minima.

Period score

Club123Final
Brooklyn Skating Club2024
New York Athletic Club1023

Scoring summary

WhenClubScorerAssistsBSC–NYAC
P1 · 08New York A.C.Max HornfeckFenwick, Baird0–1
P1 · 11Brooklyn S.C.WilliamsLiffiton1–1
P1 · 17Brooklyn S.C.LiffitonPost, Shiebler2–1
P3 · 14Brooklyn S.C.WilliamsHenderson, Shiebler3–1
P3 · 15Brooklyn S.C.Liffiton · GWGPost, Shiebler4–1
P3 · 17New York A.C.HuntKoehler, Max Hornfeck4–2
P3 · 18New York A.C.BairdKoehler4–3

Named player ledger

PlayerClubGAPTSIndividual PIMCharted SOG*
LiffitonBrooklyn Skating Club21343
ShieblerBrooklyn Skating Club03300
WilliamsBrooklyn Skating Club20204
BairdNew York Athletic Club11201
Max HornfeckNew York Athletic Club11201
KoehlerNew York Athletic Club0222≥2
PostBrooklyn Skating Club02201
HuntNew York Athletic Club10122
FenwickNew York Athletic Club01100
HendersonBrooklyn Skating Club01102
HowardNew York Athletic Club00001
JennisonBrooklyn Skating Club00000

Goalkeepers

GoalieClubGoals allowedCharted saves*Charted shots faced*
O'DonnellNew York Athletic Club4610
C. MacKenzieBrooklyn Skating Club3≥4≥7

Team figures

ClubFaceoffs wonCharted chancesCharted SOG*Individual/team PIM
Brooklyn Skating Club139104
New York Athletic Club146≥74

Penalties

WhenClubPlayerPenaltyPIM
P1 · 06Brooklyn Skating ClubLiffitonMinor2
P1 · 16New York Athletic ClubKoehlerMinor2
P1 · 19New York Athletic ClubHuntMinor2
P1 · 20Brooklyn Skating ClubLiffitonMinor2

Reading this replay

*Shots and saves count resolved charted outcomes, not every physical shot. ≥ marks a confirmed minimum. One uncertain New York A.C. attempt is excluded from exact on-goal totals; Koehler’s SOG and C. MacKenzie’s saves/shots faced are affected. Full save percentages and GAA are not asserted.

Sourced historical names use estimated abilities and roles. Five active skaters and three 20-minute periods are a modern Hockey Blast adaptation. New York A.C. is administrative home; actual home ice and venue remain unconfirmed. All 137 recorded actions, events and the complete final state were validated without new play.

The prepared dated roster supplies all twelve skaters and two goalies. Jennison has no recorded scoring, penalty or shot contribution. Historical fixture/roster reference: 1899–1900 AAHL dated archive. This is an ASN replay result.

AAHL standings and results →